The Last Axe or was it a Hatchet?

“Lizzie Borden took an axe

And gave her mother forty whacks

And when she saw what she had done

She gave her father forty one”

Traditional Rhyme

Sasha Wilson as Lizzie Borden (Photo: Reg Madison)

Bury the Hatchet  is the story of Lizzie Borden from Fall River in Massachusetts in 1892 who stool trial for the murder of her father and step mother. The show is written and narrated by Sasha Wilson as Lizzie and there is blue grass music and folk songs in it.  Two musicians, Lawrence Boothman and David Leopold accompany her on violin and guitar and she plays banjo.

In 70 minutes we get many facts from the case: details of the Irish maid Bridget Sullivan and of Andrew Borden’s second wife, Abby.  Although property developer Andrew Borden’s estate was worth $300,000 ($10 million in today’s value) when he was killed,  he was notoriously penny pinching and their house did not have indoor plumbing even though most homes did in 1892.  

The difficulty with the facts is that little scientific evidence or methods were available.  Lizzie had burnt a dress she said had been ruined by paint.  Lizzie and her sister Emma had fallen out with their step mother and often stayed away from the house in Fall River, which now is a B and B. 

Business associates had reason to dislike Andrew Borden as did John Vinnicum Morse, Abby’s brother and Lizzie and Emma’s uncle who was staying there the night before the murder. There is also speculation that Lizzie and the maid Bridget were in a Lesbian relationship which was discovered by Lizzie’s father. 

The Cast (photo: Alex Brenner)

There are no easy answers as to who murdered Andrew and Abby Borden but the lightness of the blue grass music and songs lift the murderous gloom.  The well chosen songs include Johnny Cash’s “The Wayfaring Stranger”, Art Garfunkel’s “Down in the Willow Garden” and the traditional folk song “Little Sadie” with its strong banjo accompaniment and the wonderful Nina Simone’s “Feeling Good”.

Lizzie Borden was acquitted at her trial for murder and lived in the area for another thirty years but was shunned by the people who lived there.  At the end of the show we are asked our verdict.  It is maybe a shame the Scots decision of Not Proven wasn’t an option.  I really enjoyed this show and award it Four Fringe Festival stars (FFS) from Theatrevibe, the site that doesn’t do stars.

Production Notes

Bury the Hatchet

Written by Sasha Wilson

Directed by Vicky Moran

Cast

Starring:

David Leopold

Lawrence Boothman

Sasha Wilson

Creatives

Director: Vicky Moran

Costume Designer: Helen Stewart

Lighting Designer: ill AlderW

Information

Running Time: One hour 10 minutes 

Booking to 26th August 2025

Venue: 

Pleasance Dome 

10 Dome

Bristo Square

Edinburgh EH8 9LL

https://www.pleasance.co.uk/event/crawl
 
 

Reviewed by Lizzie Loveridge at the

Pleasance Dome  

Queen Dome

on Wednesday 13th  August 2025 at 3.50pm