Is Grass Really Greener?

Henry – Strauss?
Annie – No, it can’t be Strauss. It’s in Italian
Henry – Ah, then — Verdi
Annie – Which one?
Henry – Giuseppe (he says looking really pleased with himself)

Bel Powley as Annie and James McArdle as Henry (Photo: Manuel Harlan)

The Real Thing (1982) was one of Tom Stoppard’s mid-career plays after he catapulted to fame with Rosencrantz and Guildenstern Are Dead  in 1966.  Interestingly when you look at The Real Thing’s themes of adultery and marriage, at its premiere in 1982 the role of the actress Annie was taken by Felicity Kendal who was in a partnership with Tom Stoppard for most of the 1990s. 

Early Stoppard plays are not necessarily well known.  The year before The Real Thing which must have been one of the most frank dissections of marriage and infidelity, Stoppard wrote On the Razzle a version of an Austrian 19th century musical play Einen Jux will er sich machen.  Interestingly, Stoppard left out the character that was Dolly of Hello Dolly! fame. 

I didn’t see the London opening of The Real Thing with Roger Rees and Felicity Kendall nor sadly the Tony laden Broadway version directed by Mike Nicholls starring Glenn Close and Jeremy Irons as Annie and Henry. My best play of 1999 was one I did see, at the Donmar Warehouse with the lovely Jennifer Ehle as Annie and witty actor Stephen Dillane as the articulate but emotionally unintelligent Henry. 

In 2010 I saw The Real Thing at the current venue, The Old Vic with Toby Stephens and Hattie Morahan in the lead roles.  I was disappointed then, wondering whether the play had less impact than 11 years earlier, whether the jokes fell flatter than before or whether it just felt less fresh? 

James McArdle as Henry and Susan Wokoma as Charlotte (Photo: Manuel Harlan)

So to 2024.  The first scene works very well and you’ll be surprised by the second, if you haven’t seen it before and I’m not going to spoil it, except to say how clever it is.  In the second scene we have playwright and screenwriter Henry (James McArdle) in a disintegrating marriage to Charlotte (Susan Wokoma).  Henry has met actor Max (Oliver Johnstone)’s wife Annie (Bel Powley), also an actor, and they are deeply attracted to each other.  The infidelity, like Othello,  is exposed by a handkerchief which Max finds in Annie’s car. 

One of the reasons for conflict in Henry’s relationship and later marriage to Annie is her support of a working class Scottish soldier, Brodie (Jack Ambrose) of a rebellious nature who set on fire a wreath at the Cenotaph and is serving a prison sentence.  Brodie’s appallingly written play is a source of dispute between Annie and Henry.  She is unable to see how poor a play it is because she is in a group defending Brodie and his revolutionaty ideas.

The journey in this play ought to be that of Henry.  James McArdle beautifully conveys how Henry is stuck in his life, with his delight in an erudite vocabulary and an analysis of semantics, which divert him from seeing the feelings of others.   Henry makes this mistake with both wives as he puzzles what it means to say, “I Love You.” 

Oliver Johnstone as Max. (Photo: Manuel Harlan)

It would be judgmental to say that Annie is shallow but we can feel the frisson of excitement as the nice middle-class girl gets involved with a man she perceives as a political prisoner.  Bel Powley as Annie is the youngest of the main four and her innocence contrasts with Henry’s cynicism. Later in an acting role, Annie plays Annabella in John Ford’s Jacobean Tragedy Tis Pity She’s A Whore with actor Billy (Rilwan Abiola Owokoniran) playing her brother Giovanni.  How often do we see a play about incest? 

Peter McKintosh’s set is framed by rectangles of light above and below.  As people move in and out, cardboard boxes are left either being packed or unpacked, and the lights converge for scene changes with the use of stage hands openly onstage.  Max Webster’s direction is sound.

I suppose what we are missing in The Real Thing is the glue that holds some marriages together, the impact of children and their future.  Now that is more complex to write about.

You can still enjoy Stoppardian wit and one liners and the audience clapped appreciatively but I felt a certain staleness at references to digital watches and protests at nuclear weapon bases. Henry’s inability to summon up more intellectually acceptable music for his Desert Island Disc’s appearance than Herman and the Hermits and The Righteous Brothers will have the Millennials reaching for their I watches and Google searches.  Infidelity is so much more detectable in the days of mobile phones.  The Real Thing feels dated.

Bel Powley as Annie and Rilwan Abiola Owokoniran as Billy. (Photo: Manuel Harlan)

Production Notes

The Real Thing

Written by Tom Stoppard

Directed by Max Webster

Cast

Starring:

James McArdle

Bel Powley

Oliver Johnstone

Susan Wokoma

Rilwan Abiola Owokoniran

With

Jack Ambrose

Karise Hansen

Creatives

Director: Max Webster

Designer: Peter McKintosh

Movement Director: Chi-San Howard

Lighting Designer: Richard Howell

Sound Designer: Alexandra Faye Braithwaite

Information

Running Time: Two hours 30 minutes with an interval

Booking to 26th October 2024

Theatre: 

Old Vic

The Cut

Waterloo

London SE1 8NB

Tube/Rail : Waterloo

Telephone: 0344 871 7628

Website: oldvictheatre.com

Reviewed by Lizzie Loveridge

at the Old Vic

at the final preview performance 

on 2nd September 2024