A loud, proud, colourful, inclusive, and very funny GenZ musical that will delight Millennials to Boomers
“I hope my mind is on the pill, because it’s about to be f**ked”
Oliver to Nancy on them arguing about both being single
It’s amazing at how different two days in the life of a theatre critic can be. On Monday I was teased with the launch of a brand-new show coming to London next year. It turned out to be yet another pre-2000s movie being given a musical make-over. Whilst I have no inherent dislike of turning movies into theatrical productions (and this one seems like it could be rather good), it does beg the question, what’s happened to originality?
Fast forward 24 hours and my whispered prayers were answered. The worldwide launch of a new musical that is… completely original. New music. New Lyrics. And, above all, a new story. If that wasn’t enough, it’s from the zero-to-hero creative pairing of Toby Marlow and Lucy Moss who gave the world the unexpected mega-smash hit SIX the Musical.
Following success is rarely an easy task and, it would appear, Marlow & Moss were not immune that. Fortunately, they wrote a musical about it.
Why Am I So Single? Is the story of Oliver (Jo Foster) and Nancy (Leesa Tulley), ostensibly Marlow & Moss, struggling to come up with a follow up to a smash hit musical. They’re encouraged to write something that they know about, but that’s not much help. As they struggle to come up with ideas, they ponder their respective failures at holding down a relationship and start questioning as to why each of them is single. This leads them on a journey that takes a deeper and exposing look at their friendship and, more tellingly, at themselves. This is discussed, broken apart and, ultimately, put back together against a narrative backdrop looking at sexuality, gender, society and, above all, self-reflection.
The result is a surprisingly funny and revealing story. The first half sets the scene and lays the groundwork in establishing who Oliver and Nancy are. It takes an irreverent look at their friendship and their mutually disastrous dating lives. It’s a mordaciously funny, pointed, and self-deprecating look at youth culture and teen dating in a digital first, excessive options, and instant gratification society.
We’re given a high energy look at their exciting party-led lifestyles. However, as we move into the second act, a virtual mirror is held up to them both and self-assessment sets in. What they really want, is something that’s eluding them both, a relationship.
What is wrong with them? Why can they not hold down a relationship? Why do they attract the wrong type of people?
The frivolity and joy of the first act noticeably shifts to something more reflective and sombre. Whilst notes of humour are present, the comedy is firmly on the back burner as the pair come to some important and poignant realisations about themselves and their friendship.
There are many joys to Why Am I So Single? It’s wildly bright, camp and wonderfully exuberant. The story is mildly convoluted, but refreshingly new and engaging. The songs, for the main, are just what you need. Anchored in the musical theatre genre, they also very much of today. Much like SIX, the soundtrack is modern and fresh but also immediately engaging. The lyrics effectively drive forward or add to the narrative but, crucially, keep the mood of the moment firmly in mind, be that humour, reflection, or anger.
The show is co-directed by Moss with choreographer Ellen Kane and rounded off with Moi Tran’s set design that, all combined, gives a gloriously inventive and vibrant presentation. Whoever came up with the idea of using supporting cast members as furnishings in Oliver’s flat, delivered a masterstroke of creativity.
Though the overriding narrative of the show is Oliver and Nancy reflecting on their friendship whilst trying to come up with an idea for a new musical, this is a story about something much more meaningful. It’s about respect for oneself and for others, no matter if you’re on the same page or not. It’s about acceptance, trust, community and friendship. This is a show that lets people present themselves as they want to be seen and being recognised and supported in that.
The stage is littered with the young cast proudly basking in their gender identity and sexuality. And, the simple act of Nancy regularly asking non-binary Oliver how they want to be identified as, is such an easy and powerful way of letting us know that something so simple (a question that take less than two seconds to ask) can make someone feel acknowledged and welcome.
Whilst the second act feels a bit sluggish compared to the first, it provides a much-needed emotional resolution the core narrative needs. But this doesn’t detract from the fact that Why Am I So Single? is a highly entertaining piece of original theatre that has a core message we should all pay heed to. Oh! It’s also wonderfully funny too.
Musical Numbers
Act One
Prologue
Why Am I So Single?
8 Dates
I Got Off the Plane
Why Am I So Single? (Reprise)
CU Never
Meet Market
Shhh!!!!
Just In Case
Interlude in B Minor
Act Two
Clubs Glorious Clubs
No Question
Disco Ball
Why Am I So Single?
(Reprise Pig in the City)
Men R Trash
Just In Case (Reprise)
Lost
Why Am I Still Reprising?
Better Off Love Story
Production Notes
Why Am I So Single?
Created by Toby Marlow and Lucy Moss
Directed by Lucy Moss and Ellen Kane
Choreographed by Ellen Kane
Cast
Starring:
Jo Foster
Leesa Tulley
Noah Thomas
With:
Natasha Leaver
Ran Marner
Jamel Matthias
Olivia O’Connor
Joshian Angelo Omaña
Natasha Wilde
Rhys Wilkinson
Jordan Cambridge-
Collette Guitart
Callum Bell
Owen McHugh
Caitlin Redpath
Creatives
Directors: Lucy Moss and Ellen Kane
Set Designer: Moi Tran
Costume Designer: Max Johns
Orchestrator, Vocal Arranger and Musical Supervisor: Joe Beighton
Lighting Designer: Jai Morjaria
Costume Designer: Jon Morrell
Sound Designer: Paul Gatehouse
Resident Choreographer: Ebony Clarke
Information
Running Time: Two hours 30 minutes with an interval
Booking until 13th February 2025
Theatre:
Garrick Theatre
2 Charing Cross Road
London WC2H 0HH
Phone: 0330 333 4811
Rail/Tube: Charing Cross
Reviewed by Sonny Waheed
at the Garrick Theatre, on 10th September 2024