Murderous Masculine Toxicity
“Shall I punch you five times and see what happens?”
Moat to a social worker

Why write about a murderer? Robert Icke writes and directs Manhunt about the 2010 police search to find a man released from Durham Prison after serving a short sentence. Two days after his release Raoul Thomas Moat (Samuel Edward-Cooke) had gone to a house in Birtley where his ex-girlfriend Samantha Stobbart (Sally Messham) was staying with her new manfriend Chris Brown (Leo James). Afraid of Moat, Samantha had told him that her new manfriend was a policeman. Moat already seemed to have a hatred for policemen. Moat had two children from a previous marriage and one daughter with Sam Stobbart.
The opening scene shows a man behind a gauze curtain onto which is projected a live stream rotating of the man behind. There are sounds of cages closing shut.
This play is not about understanding Moat or finding reasons for his intense anger and what is called toxic masculinity. Physically he is 6 feet 3 inches and 17 stone and short tempered. The police know that on release from prison he is making threats about his ex-girlfriend. He is released on 1st July And on 3rd July, he listens outside where Chris Brown and Sam Stobbart are discussing him. He waits for Chris Brown to come outside and shoots him dead with a sawn off shotgun. He then shoots into the house and wounds Sam, damaging her liver and resulting in her requiring hospital surgery.

From there, 22 hours later he shot a policeman PC David Rathband on traffic patrol. Rathband survived but was permanently blinded and 18th months later, having lost his job, having lost his family and having lost his sight, he committed suicide by shooting himself. This incident plunges the audience into darkness for quite a few minutes so we are able to empathise with the blinded man, just listening to Rathband’s account.
There are flashbacks to Moat’s childhood, an absentee father and another violent man who beats him. There is conflict over the earlier prison sentence, his only previous conviction, when he refuses to plead guilty to assaulting a nine year old child.

After shooting PC Rathband, Moat goes on the run and camps out near Rothbury and on 10th July shoots himself dead. Robert Icke offers no excuses or explanations for Moat’s behaviour although Moat judged himself to be a victim, saying that the police had taken from him, his job, his house, his children and Samantha. An imaginary meeting takes place between Paul Gascoigne (Trevor Fox) and Moat to try to get Moat to give himself up.
Samuel Edward-Cook gives an amazing performance, full of paranoia and feeling he is the subject of injustice. Once he also shows a softer side with his daughter Chanel but mostly he is out of control and can erupt like a firework. The ensemble cast all play their parts as police, prison officers and social workers.
I am left confused and really none the wiser by this play. What do we learn from it? Could those tragic deaths have been avoided? Should the police have warned Samantha Stobbart that she was a likely target? Yes.

Production Notes
Manhunt
Written and directed by Robert Icke
Cast
Starring:
Samuel Edward-Cook
Danny Kirrane,
Nicolas Tennant
Sally Messham
Trevor Fox
Patricia Jones
Leo James
Angela Lonsdale
Nathan Jago
Odhran Riddell
Zoe Bryan
Madeleine Mckenna
Creatives
Director: Robert Icke
Designer: Hildegard Bechtler
Lighting Designer: Azusa Ono
Fight Director: Kev McCurdy
Sound Director: Tom Gibbons
Information
Running Time: One hour 35 minutes
Booking to 3rd May 2025
Theatre:
Jerwood Theatre Downstairs
Royal Court Theatre
Sloane Square
London SW1W 4AS
Phone: 020 7565 5000
Website: royalcourttheatre.com
Tube: Sloane Square
Reviewed
by Lizzie Loveridge
at the Royal Court on 11th April 2025