The Tragedy of Admiral Byng

“Once they have a taste of power, they stick to it like limpets.”

Sailor

Cast. (Photo: Holly-Anne White)

The Playground Theatre opened in Latimer Road in 1998 specialising in new, small productions, that otherwise might not be shown. A new play Admiral Byng written and directed by Christopher Swann takes a somewhat unusual approach to the subject. 

Byng was an Admiral in charge of ten Ships of the Line in 1756, ordered to support the garrison of Fort St Philip. on the island of Menorca at Port Mahon, from the invading French, as part of the seven years war. After a short naval battle and realising the French had already captured the fort, Byng broke off the engagement and returned to England.  The history of the time is important to appreciate: Great Britain ruled the waves and any nation that opposed them became at war.  Admiral Nelson’s later maxim “England expects every man will do his duty” was paramount.  If your duty was to die for king and country, so be it.

Byng was arrested on his return and convicted of, “Failing to do his duty”.  George II said flatly, “This man will not fight!”  Byng was sentenced to death by firing squad in a public execution onboard the Monarch  in front of senior officers of the Fleet.  The satirical French writer Voltaire quipped, “il est bon de tuer de temps en temps un amiral pour encourager les autres.”  

Chris Barritt as Hutchens and Peter Tate as Byng. (Photo: Holly-Anne White)

The play centres on the last two days of Byng’s life.  He knows he is to be executed at noon on the 14th March 1757 and reflects on his past. Played by Peter Tate, he is the main character to which the other cast members relate. Chris Barritt plays his manservant Hutchens.  Boyd’s sister Sarah (Corrina McDermott) and Hervey (Merric Boyd) a naval officer and friend, are convinced he should not be killed.

To deal with the setting, author (Christopher Swann) uses two sailors played by Randy Smartnick and James Shenoi, to sing the history and its tragic outcome. The stage designed by Peter Bingemann is simple but effective; there are two large sail like panels that are moved to the sides to change scenes.

As the eventual outcome is known it presents a difficulty in holding the audience’s interest over the two hours and in this, the play failed. The first Act sets the scene but towards the end of the second Act in a dream, Voltaire, has a long debate with Byng over his future after he has died.  I could not see the benefit of this discourse and would have preferred the play to finish earlier. In conclusion unless you are interested in the history of 250 odd years ago there is little you can take from this production, it could and should be better.  

Although the court-martial recommended mercy, King George II chose not to pardon Byng. He was the second most senior Admiral in the British Navy.   To bring you up to date, despite multiple requests, including a petition from his family in 2007,  the Ministry of Defence has refused to grant him a post-humous pardon

Randy Smartnick as Sailor and James Shenoi as Sailor (photo: Holly-Anne White0

Production Notes

Admoral Byng

Written and directed by Christopher Swann

Cast

Starring:

Peter Tate

Chris Barritt

James Shenoi

Merric Boyd

Corrina McDermott

Randy Smartnick

Creatives

Director: Christopher Swann

Designer:  Peter Bingemann

Lighting Designer: Petra Vocka

Sound Designer: Christopher Swann

Information

Running Time: Two hours with an interval

Booking to 17th May 2025

Theatre:  

Playground Theatre

Latimer Road

London W10 6RQ

RG20 8AE

Box Office: boxoffice@theplaygroundtheatre.org.uk

Website:  theplaygroundtheatre.org.uk

Reviewed by Malcolm Beckett

at the Playground Theatre

on 1st May 2025