Ghost Stories – Are They Always Invented?

“Do you believe in ghosts?”

Professor Goodman

Ghost Stories (Photo: Hugo Glendinning)

Ghost stories tend to follow a familiar formula: a slow build-up leading to an uncertain finish. That was my expectation at the Peacock Theatre. The audience sat quietly, waiting for the Safety Curtain to rise. The house lights were on, and We Are Sitting Comfortably.

Suddenly, the lights went out. It was pitch black. Loud noises erupted, mixed with a woman’s screams. After a short while, the lights came back on, revealing a single lectern to the side of the stage in front of the Safety Curtain. A man walked on, dressed to give a lecture, Professor Goodman (Jonathan Guy Lewis), who has studied the paranormal.

He invites the audience to raise their hands if they believed in ghosts, a few do. Then he asks if anyone had experienced a manifestation, fewer hands, but still a countable number.

He announces that there are no such things as ghosts; what people experience are things their minds want them to believe; they are Percipients. His talk continues, but he begrudgingly concedes that there were three instances he could not automatically dismiss.

Clive Mantle as Mike Priddle. (Photo: Hugo Glendinning)

The Safety Curtain rises showing a grubby workers office occupied by The First Subject, a night watchman, Tony Matthews (David Cardy) who at a quarter to four starts hearing strange noises on his round testing the security locks, a bad mistake, the house lights go out, a child screams in the dark, something happens

Curtain rises again showing a car with piercing headlights, pointing into the auditorium The Second Subject, a young man, Simon Rifkind (Preston Nyman) is driving home at night and arguing with his parents on the phone. It is foggy.  You might guess what happens next but you might be wrong.

Finally, a bare room with a child’s cot and newborn paraphernalia.  The Third Subject,  a self obsessed bond trader always answering “urgent calls” is  Mike Priddle (Clive Mantle).  He describes the attempts he and his wife had to finally conceive a child, a new treatment for people who may be desperate. Things start to take a peculiar turn.

Professor Goodman, clearly an agnostic, tries to explain the events away, but he himself is drawn into the stories. The tension rises. Events become louder and more frequent. The audience grows uneasy.

It would be a shame to spoil what happens in this well crafted production. I can say that the writers/directors Jeremy Dyson and Andy Nyman, with Sean Holms also directing, and Jon Bausor (Set and Costume Designer), combined with Scott Penrose (Special Effects), have created a good, entertaining, and scary play of 85 minutes. The cast and crew deliver a believable experience. Given the time of year, it’s certainly worth a visit.

David Carry as Tony Matthews (Photo: Hugo Glendinning)

Production Notes

Ghost Stories

Written by Jeremy Dyson and Andy Nyman

Directed by Jeremy Dyson, Andy Nyman and Sean Holmes

Cast

Starring:

Jonathan Guy Lewis

David Cardy

Clive Mantle

Preston Nyman

Lloyd McDonagh

Simon Bass  

Harry Rundle

 

Creatives

Directors: Jeremy Dyson, Andy Nyman and Sean Holmes

Designer: Jon Bausor

Lighting Designer:  James Farncombe

Sound Designer: Nick Manning
 
 
Special Effects: Scott Penrose

 

Fight Director:  Jonathan Holby

 

Information

Running Time: One hour 25 minutes 

Booking to 8th November 2025

Theatre: 

Peacock Theatre

Portugal Street

London WC2A 2HT

Tube : Holborn

Website: sadlerswells.com

Reviewed by Malcolm Beckett

at the Peacock Theatre

on 9th October 2025