Play about Inequality becomes Unbearable

“I don’t pay you to speak back.”

Madame

Lydia Wilson as Claire and Phil Saban as Solange. (Photo: Marc Brenner)

With over 28 years reviewing, I have managed to avoid The Maids on all but one occasion in 2016 when Jamie Lloyd directed the play based in the American South at Trafalgar Studios.  Seeing it at the Donmar Warehouse, I have no desire to see it ever again.

Kip Williams who was so fêted for his one-woman Dorian Gray with Sarak Snook directs an updated version which largely ignores the original crime. It has been said to be based on the Papin sisters who murdered their employer and her daughter in Le Mans in 1933, although Genet denied this. 

The opening scene, behind gauze curtains, in a room filled with bouquets of pink flowers, sees two women playing out a version of their life with their cruel employer.  Solange (Phia Saban) plays the Maid Claire and her sister, the real Claire (Lydia Wilson) plays their mistress, only called the Madame. 

Lydia Wilson as Claire and Yerin Ha as Madame. (Photo: Marc Brenner)

The monologues are so strident and screechy, this play is as close to an impossible watch as I can remember in decades. Behind the gauze, Claire as Madame, bullies and is unspeakable towards the sister playing the maid.  Wearing Madame’s designer red frock with its exaggerated hip bustles, Claire films herself on a mobile phone using a filter to enhance her facial features, her eyes overly large and a bright colour, her nose refined and her lips red, swollen and huge as if stung by a flight of bees. 

I found myself thinking about the recent pictures of the American AI actress, although the supposed enhancement here is so over the top as to be ugly.  Pretending to be Claire, Solange bites back and her phone screen image is aged to make her twice her age, her teeth loosened and oversized and falling out.  I wondered if this is what AI will do to live theatre.

Using the phone transformation, Solange becomes the handsome man who is Madame’s boyfriend, in court accused of fraud.

Lydia Wilson as Claire (Photo: Marc Brenner)

These maids are amazingly articulate, despite their presumed lack of education but the audience are not laughing at their excesses of language and hatred. An image of a maid looks like a young version of Angelina Jolie. Knowing that she is coming home the maids get the room ready from its chaos of strewn flowers for Madame’s return. 

Then we have the arrival of Madame (Yerin Ha) a billionaire shallow social influencer and this is maybe the only positive I have about this production is that it exposes the superficial claim to fame of the social influencer.  She will switch from praising her maids to belligerent anger and abuse.  I am so sorry that I could not like this production from one of my three favourite London theatres. 

Yerin Ha as Madame and Lydia Wilson as Claire (Photo by Marc Brenner)_

Production Notes

 The Maids

Written by Jean Genet

 Adapted and directed by Kip Williams

Cast

Starring:

Lydia Wilson

Phia Saban

Yerin Ha

Creatives

Director: Kip Williams

Set Designer: Rosanna Vize

Costume Designer: Marg Horwell

Lighting Designer: Jon Clarke

Composer: DJ Walde

Sound designer: Dan Balfour
 
 
Video/projection designer: Zakk Hein
 
 
 

Information

Running Time: One hour 40 minutes 

Booking to 29th November 2025

Theatre: 

Donmar Warehouse

Earlham Street

Covent Garden

London WC2H 9LX

Tube : Covent Garden

Website: donmarwarehouse.com

Reviewed by Lizzie Loveridge

at the Donmar Warehouse

on 22nd October 2025