Tom Stoppard's Masterly Arcadia

 

“There is nothing more to be said about sexual congress.”  Septimus
“Is it the same as love?”   Thomasina
“Oh no, it is much nicer than that.”  Septimus

“It is a defect of God’s humour that he directs our hearts everywhere but to those who have a right to them”.

Lady Croom.

Seamus Dillane as Septimus Hodge and Isis Hainsworth as Lady Thomasina Coverly. (Photo: Manuel Harlan)

There are many who think that the late Tom Stoppard is Britain’s best 20th century playwright and that Arcadia (first published 1993) is his best play.  How brilliant of the Old Vic to stage it now so soon after the death of the playwright on 29th November last year! 

The real Arcadia was a landlocked region of Greece where the Arcadians lived a pastoral and isolated existence.  In Greek and Roman poetry and Renaissance literature, the term Arcadia is interchangeable with an idealized country living, a kind of rural paradise.

Arcadia is set in two distinct time periods, around 1810 and in the 1990s.  In the course of the play, we examine algebra and algorithms, fashions in garden design, Byron’s peccadilloes and many more possible diversions that the playwright allows us to expand mentally. The key with Stoppard is the way he satisfies so many of the audience and how detailed is his immaculate research.

Gabriel Akuwudike as Richard Noakes and Fiona Button as Last Croom. (Photo: Manuel Harlan)

Those who want to observe people are satisfied, those who relish Ancient and more modern literature will be engaged, those who want to chuckle will find plenty to amuse but those whose want to grapple with scientific concepts can do so, without the rest of us who may be non scientists, feeling adrift. In the scene towards the end of the play when both time periods happen at once, the twenty-first century cast are dressed for a costume ball so the dress is similar to their ancestors.

There is plenty of Stoppard’s famously clever wit, whether it’s her tutor Septimus Hodge (Seamus Dillane) gulling Thomasina Coverly (Isis Hainsworth) into thinking carnal embrace is the practice of throwing one’s arms round a side of beef or Lady Croom (Fiona Button) wryly observing, “It is a defect of God’s humour that he directs our hearts everywhere but to those who have a right to them.”

The disastrous gardener Mr Noakes (Gabriel Akuwudike) is compared unfavourably with the most brilliant of eighteenth century landscape designers, Capability Brown, by his being dubbed Culpability Noakes by Lady Croom. It is Noakes’ work which is changing the gardens of Sidley Park from the natural but romantic Arcadia to the over styled and pretentious Gothic.

Seamus Dillane as Septimus Hodge. (Photo: Manuel Harlan)

The modern scenes feature Bernard Nightingale (Prasanna Puwanarajah) a university lecturer from Sussex researching poet Mr Chater (Matthew Steer) and Chater’s flirtatious wife’s past with Lord Byron.  Bernard’s discovery trail reads like a mystery thriller and in opposition to him in the 1990s is Sidley Park resident cynic Hannah Jarvis (Leila Farzad).  In this production I found Prasanna Puwanarajah’s character more charming than I had in 2009 at the Duke of York’s and here Hannah to be unkind but the verbal sparring between them is a delight. It is Augustus Coverly (William Lawlor)’s stored game books recording game shot which are kept in a commode which contribute evidence. 

The final half hour like the circular Venn overlap in the ceiling’s set by designer, Alex Eales, has characters from both time periods on stage but playing separate scenes. The theatre is in its circular formation with the set able to revolve, a simple round mahogany table forming the centrepiece in both eras. Suzanne Cave’s costumes are lovely although the production photos are rather dark as a result of the sudued and often candle lit lighting. 

I can’t praise this intellectual and stellar production highly enough.  Carrie Cracknell shows great skill as director and gets brilliant and believable performances from all. Hopefully Sir Tom Stoppard is watching all this from Heaven and realising how much we miss him and his delicious wit. 

Five stars from Theatrevibe, the site that doesn’t do stars, for the Old Vic’s magnificent production of Arcadia

Prasanna Puwanarajah as Bernard Nightingale (Photo: Manuel Harlan)
Isis Hainsworth as Lady Thomasina Coverly. (Photo: Manuel Harlan)

Production Notes

Arcadia

Written by Tom Stoppard

Directed by Carrie Cracknell

Cast

Starring:

Gabriel Akuwudike

David Buttle

Fiona Button

Angus Cooper

Seamus Dillane

Leila Farzad

Tim Frances

Holly Godliman

Isis Hainsworth

Keziah Hayes

William Lawlor

George Lorimer

Colin Mace,

Prasanna Puwanarajah,

Lizzie Schenk

Matthew Steer

 

Creatives

Director:  Carrie Cracknell

Set Designer: Alex Eales

Costume Designer: Suzanne Cave

Lighting Designer: Guy Hoare

Sound Director: Donato Wharton

Movement: Ira Mandela Siobhan

Composer : Sturt Earl

Information

Running Time: Three hours including an interval

Booking to 21st March 2026

Theatre: 

Old Vic

The Cut

Waterloo

London SE1 8NB

Tube/Rail : Waterloo

Telephone: 0344 871 7628

Website: oldvictheatre.com

Reviewed by Lizzie Loveridge

at the Old Vic

at the final preview performance 

on 3rd February 2026