Envy is a Deadly Sin

“I’m glad my child died, she would only have been a grief to me.”

Agatha Payne

Julia Watson as Lucy Amorest, Abigail Thaw as Agatha Payne and Catherine Cusack as May Beringer. (Photo: Carla Joy Evans)

It is 1935 and in an English cathedral city Lucy Amarest (Julia Watson), a genial widow is letting out rooms to eke out her finances and to make her less lonely.  Mrs Amarest is introducing her newest lodger to the house.  Miss May Berenger (Catherine Cusack) is hoping to find a position as she too has fallen on hard times.  1934 is in the middle of the Great Depression when everyone’s savings took a knock.  Miss Berenger is of a nervous disposition and anxious.  She has lost her only companion a wire-haired fox terrier called Pip. What she has now and values with emotion is a gift from a deceased friend, a large piece of amber the size of a grapefruit and the shape of a crystal.

There is another lodger, Mrs Agatha Payne (Abigail Thaw) also widowed, dressed in an old fashioned black frock with lace and a few cheap but inconspicuous necklaces.  As Lucy Amarest talks to her new guest Miss Berenger, sitting in her own room, at the back of the three rooms in one set, is the sinister figure of Mrs Payne.  Juliette Demoulin’s set serves as Mrs Amarest’s communal room, at the rear Mrs Payne’s room and to the right, Miss Berenger’s single bed.  All is low lit atmosphere by Mark Dymock.  They all agree on the beauty of Mrs Amarest’s candle lit surprise Christmas tree.

Mrs Amarest hasn’t heard from her son for too many years and misses him terribly. She has however been told by her cousin that he will leave her £1,000 a year, an absolute fortune in 1935 and worth about £92,000 today.  Finding out the amount, has Mrs Payne hoping that Mrs Amarest will give her some of it.  This sets up Mrs Payne’s envious and avaricious character with some admirable facial acting by Abigail Thaw, daughter of Inspector Morse’s John Thaw.  Mrs Payne seems permanently to have an unpleasant smell under her nose. 

Julia Watson as Lucy Amorest, Abigail Thaw as Agatha Payne and Catherine Cusack as May Beringer. (Photo: Carla Joy Evans)

Miss Berenger has taken an instant dislike to Mrs Payne and reports to Mrs Amarest that she hears knocking on her wall throughout the night which deprives her of sleep.  We do not actually see Mrs Payne knocking on the wall but we are convinced that she is capable of it. May Berenger takes no care over her appearance, her greasy hair has been nowhere near a hairdresser and her severe side parting is secured with a plain slide.  I found myself cringing at her attempts to be nice but feeling very afraid of Mrs Payne.  The idea that she would get employment as a Lady’s companion given her lack of personality is almost laughable.  We are told Miss Berenger suffers from poor health with issues to do with her heart. Acting credits of course to Catherine Cusack, daughter of the great Irish actor Cyril Cusack and half sister to actors Sorcha, Sinead and Niamh.  Her portrayal of May is full of neuroticism and lacking in confidence. 

It is Mrs Payne who is the catalyst for the main events of Rodney Ackland’s play derived from Hugh Walpole’s 1925 novel of the same name.  She lusts after Miss Berenger’s amber and is determined to possess it.  No spoilers from me but Brigid Larmour’s direction (she directed the 1936 Merchant of Venice) conveys the suspense along with Abigail Thaw’s eye rolling avarice, disdain and cruelty.  Julia Watson’s character acts as a foil for the other two.

The play is a microcosm of domestic events in an era of gloom with Max Pappenheim’s sound design making us jump each time someone knocks at the door. 

It is very interesting to have a revival of one of Rodney Ackland’s plays besides Before the Party seen at the Almeida in 2013 and we can rely on the excellent Finborough to remind us of this author/screenwriter who worked with Somerset Maugham and Alfred Hitchcock.

Abigail Thaw as Agatha Payne and Julia Watson as Lucy Amorest, (Photo: Carla Joy Evans)

Production Notes

The Old Ladies

Written by Rodney Ackland

Directed by Brigid Larmour

Cast

Starring:

Catherine Cusack

Julia Watson

Abigail Thaw

Creatives

Director: Brigid Larmour

Set Designer: Juliette Demoulin

Costume Designer: Carla Joy Evans

Lighting Designer:  Mark Dymock

Composer and Sound Designer: Max Pappenheim

Information

Running Time: One hour 25 minutes 

Booking to 19th April 2026

Theatre: 

Finborough Theatre

118 Finborough Road

Earls Court

London

SW10 9ED

Box Office: www.finboroughtheatre.co.uk

Reviewed by Lizzie Loveridge

at the Finborough

on  26th March 2026