Lies and Double Bluff in a Marriage

“Oh damn the English!  Sometimes I think that their bad form doesn’t just lie in revealing their emotions, it’s in having any at all.”

Lydia

Claire Price as Lydia Cruttwell (Photo: Ellie Kurttz)

Love is manifested in different ways.  Rattigan’s plays were criticised with the advent of the Angry Young Men like John Osborne’s Jimmy Porter in Look Back in Anger and the kitchen sink dramas in 1950s and 60s film.  Noel Coward too got similar “out of fashion” criticism except that in the mid 60s, his plays were revived and celebrated.  In In Praise of Love the characters lie to each other as an expression of their love.

Claire Price leads this 1970s play as Lydia Cruttwell, an Estonian married to an English writer Sebastian Cruttwell (Dominic Rowan).  Lydia seems long suffering and resigned to her husband’s rudeness and lack of consideration.  He can’t even pour his own glass of whisky and complains his reading lamp doesn’t go on or that the heating isn’t working. It is very hard to write in depth about this play without revealing spoilers.  Lydia is hiding that she has a terminal illness from Sebastian while she makes plans for him and his stream of demands after she is dead. 

Visiting Sebastian and Lydia is Mark Walters (Daniel Abelson) an old friend, a very successful novelist, who is attracted to Lydia and whom she can confide in.  Sebastian, despite his middle-class lifestyle counts himself an old fashioned Marxist and despises his son Joey (Joe Edgar)’s working for the Liberal Party on a mid-term by-election. Sebastian calls the Liberals “crypto-fascists”.  Joey has himself written a play which is to be televised by the BBC that week.

Claire Price as Lydia and Daniel Abelson as Mark Walters (Photo: Ellie Kurttz)

Sebastian knows that Lydia is ill and receiving treatment but she gives him a written report that says she is improving although the result of a biopsy is needed.  I often think it is hardest to act deception but Claire Price does remarkably well as Lydia when dissembling to Sebastian.  Her first plan for taking care of Sebastian is to recruit a woman he has been seeing secretly and she assumes she is his mistress because of the number of nights he stays at his club after seeing this woman. 

Lydia tries for a dry run by planning a break with Daniel and recruiting the mysterious woman to care for Sebastian.  Of course the result is a debacle – a double bluff by both. Lies are so confusing.  At the interval we were asking why Lydia was staying with this cantankerous man, now less successful as an author but a successful and venomous critic, not for the Daily Worker, but a Sunday newspaper with a completely different political agenda. 

Joe Edgar as Joey and Claire Price as Lydia (Photo: Ellie Kurttz)

A scene between Mark and Sebastian casts some light on why Lydia needed to get married to escape from Russian controlled Berlin and just how torturous her life had been during the war.  With Estonia merged into the Soviet Union, she was in danger.  We are now convinced of the obligation she has towards her husband.  Amelia Sears directs well in a naturalistic way and Peter Butler’s anonymous set doesn’t provide corners for anyone to hide. There is more deception when Lydia tries to cover up Sebastian letting down 20 year old Joey by protecting Joey’s feelings.  

We know that Rattigan was suffering from Leukaemia when he wrote this play and also that he had observed the actor Rex Harrison’s beautiful third wife Kay Kendall die from the same disease.  Later Rex Harrison played the Sebastian part in New York and angered Rattigan by refusing to act as harshly as written.  Fortunately Dominic Rowan has no such scruples and his anger is believable.    

This play has many complexities and ideas to discuss with good acting performances from the quartet. Lydia says, “Honesty is the thing that matters least between two people who love each other.”   Do you agree?

Dominic Rowan as Sebastian Cruttwell and Claire Price as Lydia Cruttwell (Photo: Ellie Kurttz)

Production Notes

In Praise of Love

Written by Terence Rattigan

Directed by Amelia Sears

Cast

Starring:

Claire Price

Daniel Abelson

Dominic Rowan

Joe Edgar

Creatives

Director: Amelia Seara

Designer:  Peter Butler

Lighting Designer: Bethany Gupwell

Fight Director: Alex Payne

Composer and Sound Designer:  Elizabeth Purnell

Information

Running Time: Two hours 30 minutes including an interval

Booking to 3rd July 2025

Theatre: 

Orange Tree Theatre

1 Clarence Street,

Richmond,

Surrey

TW9 2SA

Phone: 020 8940 3633

Websiteorangetreetheatre.co.uk

Rail/Tube: Richmond

Reviewed by Lizzie Loveridge

at the Orange Tree

on 3rd May 2025