Victorian Celebrity High Comedy
“Is it too late to change it now? as God said when he made Swinburne.”
Oliver Blayds

So often I go to the Finborough Theatre in Earls Court and delight in the plays the Artistic Director Neil McPherson has selected to revive or produce for the very first time. In this case, The Truth About Blayds is a play from Alan Alexander Milne which the New York wit Dorothy Parker called “a fine and merciless and honest play.” Now AA Milne is best known for his creation of the bear Winnie-the-Pooh and the inhabitants of 100 Acre Wood, but he wrote many plays and if they are of the quality of this one, then I want to see them.
The sheer detail of Alex Marker’s set is impressive: the drawing room and study of the house in Portman Square of the poet Oliver Blayds on his 90th birthday. A Georgian fireplace and Georgian chairs, gentle morning light from the blinded windows at the rear with the outline of leaves and a magnificent period desk. An oil painting of the poet dominates the room.
Admitted to this inner sanctum is the literary critic, AL Royce (Rupert Wickham) who has been granted an audience with the great man on his special day. Many more have been turned away. Royce is being welcomed by the poet’s grandson and namesake, Oliver Blayds-Conway and his sister Septima (Lucy Jamieson) who is named after one of her grandfather’s famous poems. The house is full of letters from the rich and literary famous including an autographed letter from Queen Victoria.

The poet’s unmarried daughter Isobel Blayds (Catherine Cusack) has a romantic past with AL Royce forged 18 years ago but he married someone else and his wife has now died. She advises Royce not to mention the controversial 1863 volume to the nonagenarian as it has been the subject of negative criticism. The great man is wheeled in, in a dressing gown and velvet slippers and recalls meeting Royce 18 years ago.
Royce has been charged with presenting the address of letters of praise from the younger writers. There is gossip about Tennyson and Swinburne, and George Meredith poet of The Lark Ascending. There are plenty of opportunities to laugh at the wit of the conversation. Suddenly the old man panics and calls for Isabel whom we learn has chosen to devote her life to caring for her father.

After the interval, the family is clad in black and the discussion is about whether Oliver Blayds should have been buried in Poets Corner in Westminster Abbey? The light is getting darker with the subject matter. There are fine performances throughout but we marvel at William Gaunt’s recall and Catherine Cookson’s desiccated and broken life given up to her father. This is the point that I cannot continue with the narrative because it would not only be a spoiler it would prevent your enjoyment of the exciting denouement of this play and the brilliantly set up consequences and proposed solutions, each more and more fascinating, inventive and dishonest.
David Gilmore has done an excellent job in directing The Truth about Blayds and I have no hesitation in awarding this creative production five stars from Theatrevibe, the theatre site that doesn’t award stars.


Production Notes
The Truth About Blayds
Written by Alan Alexander Milne
Directed by David Gilmore
Cast
Starring:
Catherine Cusack
Karen Archer
Oliver Beamish
Rupert Wickham
William Gaunt
George Rowlands
Lucy Jamieson
Creatives
Director: David Gilmore
Set Designer: Alex Marker
Costume Designer: Carla Joy Evans
Lighting Designer: Jonathan Simpson
Information
Running Time: Two hours 15 minutes with an interval
Booking to 4th October 2025
Theatre:
Finborough Theatre
118 Finborough Road
Earls Court
London
SW10 9ED
Box Office: www.finboroughtheatre.co.uk
Reviewed by Lizzie Loveridge
at the Finborough
on 20th September 2025