Israel v Gaza in an Edgware family
“Things are happening in Gaza that shouldn’t be happening.”
Ruth Rosenberg

Ryan Craig’s 2011 play The Holy Rosenbergs looks at the issues surrounding the Goldstone Report on Human Rights in the 2009 war between Israel and Gaza. Instead of focussing just on the political and global responses, Ryan Craig places differing views in the context of a Jewish family in Edgware, London. Relevant as it was in 2011, the 7th October 2024 hostage taking and even more recent events in Iran make the timing of this revival especially pertinent.
David Rosenberg (Nicholas Woodeson) whose family came to London from Hitler’s Germany in the 1930s is coping with a fall in business for his traditional Kosher catering company. As patriarch, David is very proud of his family history causing his son to quip that they had a relative at The Last Supper. His wife Lesley (Tracy-Ann Oberman) is trying to hold her family together in the community and to ease David’s worries affecting his health.
Their son Daniel had emigrated to Israel and has been killed as a pilot in the Israeli Defence Force (IDF). Daniel’s memorial service is due the next day at a synagogue in Edgware. Daniel’s elder sister, Ruth (Dorothea Myer-Bennett), qualified as a lawyer is working in Geneva on the United Relations report on human rights in the Israeli-Gaza conflict of a couple of years earlier.

The initial findings of the report have reached Edgware and have not been well received by Jewish families who back the existence of Israel as a Jewish homeland. The anger locally focuses on Ruth Rosenberg’s contribution to the report.
The Rosenburg’s third son Jonathan (Nitai Levi) is not inclined to continue in the family business and is rebelling against his father’s plans for him. The first scene sees Jonny opening the door to Rabbi Simon (Alex Zur) who calls to advise that Ruth should not attend the memorial service because of a planned protest.
We meet two other characters in the play: the first is Saul Morganstern (Dan Fredenburgh) president of the synagogue, a consultant obstetrician and who is planning his daughter Caroline’s wedding to be catered by David Rosenberg. Saul has trouble raising the issue of anti-Ruth Rosenberg protests impacting on his daughter’s wedding celebration. Saul has been invited to dinner at the Rosenbergs ostensibly to sign the contract. Lesley Rosenberg as excellently played by Tracy-Ann Oberman fusses round the dinner table and guests with marble cake, blinis and home-made macaroons.

The final arrival to deliver a report to Ruth is Sir Stephen Crossley (Adrian Lukis) who is the eminent Human Rights lawyer who has chaired the report findings for the United Nations. The debate between the articulate, persuasive lawyer and the impassioned British Jew, Saul starts at opposite poles but ends with a handshake proffered and accepted.
All the performances are creditable but for me Dorothea Myer Bennet’s Ruth is an independent and highly principled professional with a slightly cynical or sardonic turn of phrase who finds herself in conflict with her father. You will also laugh at many of Lesley Rosenberg’s Jewish Momma actions in a brilliant piece of character acting by Tracy-Ann Oberman.
We know that the debates are contrived by the author but they all raise the problem of a situation where the rights and wrongs are blurred by pre-held views on the right of Israel to exist and of Gaza to provide a safe country for their inhabitants. It appears that Daniel had become troubled by his role in the war and the extent of civilian casualties.
Lindsay Posner as director presents the issues with clarity in a play that may have even more relevance than when it was first shown at the National. Think about 2025 yellow ribbons in North west London and the unprovoked attacks on Jewish families many of whom do not agree with the deaths in Gaza. It is a minefield.

Production Notes
The Holy Rosenbergs
Written by Ryan Craig
Directed by Lindsay Posner
Cast
Starring:
Tracy-Ann Oberman
Adrian Lukis
Nicholas Woodeson
Alex Zur
Dan Fredenburgh
Dorothea Myer-Bennett
Nitai Levi
Creatives
Director: Ryan Craig
Designer: Tim Shortall
Lighting Designer: Charles Balfour
Fight Director: Bret Yount
Sound Director: Yvonne Gilbert
Information
Running Time: Two hours 20 minutes including an interval
Booking to 2nd May 2026
Theatre:
Menier Chocolate Factory
4 O’Meara Street
London SE1 1TE
020 7378 1713
Tube: London Bridge
Reviewed by Lizzie Loveridge
at the Chocolate Factory
on 10th March 2026

