John Proctor is the Villain. Discuss.

Nell “Were you watching when he dropped the chalk last week? When he bent over to get it?

Ivy Oh my god wait have you seen how big his feet are?

Nell Big feet don’t necessarily mean anything about like the size of other things.

Miya James as Raelynn Nix, Holly Howden Gilchrist as Beth Powell, Lauryn Ajufo as Nell Shaw and Clare Hughes as Ivy Watkins. (Photo: Camilla Greenwell)

John Proctor is the Villain is an important contemporary play by Kimberly Belflower, successfully updating our understanding of victims and power dynamics. John Proctor himself was a real man, hanged during the Salem Witch Trials, in which nineteen people were executed between 1692 and 1693. These events form the basis of Arthur Miller’s classic 1956 play The Crucible, written as an allegory for McCarthyism and the anti‑communist investigations of the early 1950s.

Belflower relocates the story from seventeenth‑century Salem to a small, one‑stoplight town in Northeast Georgia in 2018. Teaching methods have shifted to reflect modern ideas of inclusion, and the set by AMP featuring Teresa Williams is a deliberately unstructured high school classroom for late‑teen students, with desks and chairs scattered in loose formation.

The class is full except for one seat. Their teacher, Carter Smith (Dónal Finn), a young, charismatic figure, opens with the provocative prompt: “Sex.” The students respond in unison with textbook definitions. They are studying The Crucible, exploring who the villain is and why.

Cast (Photo: Camilla Greenwell)

When the class ends, four girls remain: Nell Shaw (Lauryn Ajufo), Raelynn Nix (Miya James), Beth Powell (Holly Howden Gilchrist) and Ivy Watkins (Claire Hughes). They form the school’s Feminism Club. Each has her own perspective on sex from “not before marriage” to “what’s the problem, I do it now” alongside the usual teenage gossip, including their shared admiration for Taylor Swift.

The boys are largely immature and peripheral, but the same cannot be said of the attractive teacher, Mr Smith, whose marriage and child are treated almost as inconveniences. Another girl, Shelby Holcomb (Sadie Soverall), arrives late after a long absence. Her story becomes central: did Mr Smith get Shelby pregnant, and if so, what should happen?

Belflower’s writing and Danya Taymor’s direction deserve considerable credit. Multiple storylines unfold, yet the play never loses sight of its central question. In The Crucible, Proctor’s affair with his young servant is often downplayed in favour of his final moral stand; telling the truth about the innocent people condemned as witches, even though it costs him his life.

Dónal Finn as Carter Smith. (Photo: Camilla Greenwell)

In contrast, Belflower asks us to reconsider this dynamic through a modern lens. If Mr Smith has had sex with a minor, has he abused his position? The play invites us to remember figures like Harvey Weinstein and the broader cultural reckoning around power and consent. Although the school governors suspend Mr Smith, he is reinstated “Due to Lack of Evidence”. The ending makes striking use of Lorde’s song “Green Light”.  

This is a serious, sharply written play, enriched with moments of humour and structured with impressive clarity. 

John Proctor is the Villain fully deserves the attention it is receiving, and I strongly recommend seeing it.

Molly McFadden as Bailey Gallagher, Dónal Finn as Carter Smith, Miya James as Raelynn Nix, Clare Hughes as Ivy Watkins, Holly Howden Gilchrist as Beth Powell, and Lauryn Ajufo as Nell Shaw. (Photo: Camilla Greenwell)
Sadie Soverall as Shelby Holcomb and Miya James as Raelynn Nix. (Photo: Camilla Greenwell)

Production Notes

John Proctor is the Villain

Written by Kimberly Belflower

Directed by Danya Taymor

Cast

Starring:

Dónal Finn

Lauryn Ajufo

Miya James

Sadie Soverall

Holly Howden Gilchrist

Clare Hughes

Charlie Borg

Reece Braddock

Molly McFadden

Creatives

Director: Danya Taymor

Scenography:  AMP featuring Teresa Williams

Costume Designer: Sarah Laux

Lighting Designer: Natasha Katze

Movement Director:  Tilly Evans-Krueger

Projection Designer:  Hannah Wasileski

Sound Director and Composer: Palmer  Hefferan

Information

Running Time: One hour 45 minutes without an interval

Booking to 25th April 2026

Theatre: 

Jerwood Theatre Downstairs

Royal Court Theatre

Sloane Square

London SW1W 4AS

Phone: 020 7565 5000

Website: royalcourttheatre.com

Tube: Sloane Square

Reviewed by Malcolm Beckett

at the Royal Court

at on 27th March 2026