Soporific Cat on a Hot Tin Roof

I’m not living with you. We just occupy the same cage.  

Maggie


Daisy Edgar-Jones as Maggie. (Photo: Marc Brenner)

It is very interesting that Rebecca Frecknall has made her reputation directing the plays of Tennessee Williams when so many of his characterisations of women are so unkind. Can you think of a sympathetic female character in his plays?  Maybe the self-deluded Blanche Dubois and her sister Stella in A Streetcar Named Desire?  The mentally adrift sister Laura in A Glass Menagerie was based on his own sister but her mother Amanda doesn’t shine with motherly love but unbridled ambition.

So we come to Maggie, Brick’s wife (Daisy Edgar-Jones) in Cat on a Hot Tin Roof, married to a man who doesn’t feel for her sexually and who is drowning himself in drink.  At the Almeida, I wasn’t convinced by the lust and desire Maggie is meant to feel and the starkness of Brick (Kingsley Ben-Adir)’s rejection of her.  Tall and thin and dressed for the most part in a silver tube dress, Daisy Edgar-Jones’ rampant feline characterisation only came alive for me in Marc Brenner’s wonderful production photographs and not on stage.  Not even crawling on the baby grand piano was convincing. 

Kingsley Ben-Adir as Brick (Photo: Marc Brenner)

In this production, all our sympathy and concern is with Kingsley Ben-Adir’s Brick, the personification of what can go wrong when one child is so preferred over his elder brother Gooper (Ukwell Roach) and he is expected to provide an heir to his father Big Daddy (Lennie James)’s estate.  Big Daddy too has fallen out of love with his wife Big Mama (Clare Burt) whom he describes as fat but the rest of us see her as not fat.  Big Mama dotes on her younger son, the handsome Brick. 

There is a pianist (Set Carrington) onstage sentenced to lurk when he is not playing but I’ve no idea why?  The sound scape is strange tinkling of notes.  Chloe Lamford’s set is giant walls comprised of glass bricks implying that there is no privacy and everyone is spying on everyone else.

Clara Burt as Big Mama and Kingsley Ben-Adir as Brick. (Photo: Marc Brenner)

There will be discussion about the casting in this production.  Some years ago, there was a magnificent production of Cat on a Hot Tin Roof with an all black cast, starring James Earl Jones as Big Daddy and Adrian Lester as Brick.  In the Almeida’s production, Big Daddy is black, his sons and grandchildren are of dual heritage but the grown women are all white.  Are we meant to notice this?  Is it colour blind casting or of significance as the power politics of the South shift potentially to black men in charge and white women in wedded servitude?

Lennie James as Big Daddy (Photo: Marc Brenner)

The whole show seems a long, exhausting night at three hours including the interval.  It was a decision to incorporate the various different versions of the play text.  It was worked on because it wasn’t perfect and maybe the final version should have been more respected. In particular the first act is entirely Maggie’s and is screaming out for some editing because of the repetitions. 

It improves as we meet more characters in the second act but again slows in the despair of the final act.   I am a huge admirer of Lennie James but the standout star here is Kingsley Ben-Adir’s crippled ego as Brick. 

I would recommend that Rebecca Frecknall branch out into directing other playwrights.  Her Romeo and Juliet was interesting and we shall see more of her in her new appointment alongside Rupert Gould at the Old Vic.

Daisy Edgar-Jones as Maggie. (Photo: Marc Brenner)

Production Notes

Cat on a Hot Tin Roof

Written by Tennessee Williams

Directed by Rebecca Frecknall

Cast

Starring:

Kingsley Ben-Adir

Clare Burt

Daisy Edgar-Jones

Derek Hagen

Guy Burgess

Lennie James

Pearl Chanda

Seb Carrington

Ukweli Roach

Grace Ledger

Asa Jones

Elyssa Perkins

Creatives

Director: Rebecca Frecknall

Set Designer:  Chloe Lamford

Costume Designer: Moi Tran

Composer: Angus Macra

Lighting Designer:  Lee Curran

Sound Designer: Carolyn Dowling

Fight Director: Sam Lyon-Behan

Information

Running Time: Three hours including an interval

Booking to 1st February 2025 

Theatre:

Almeida Theatre 

Almeida Street

London N1 1TA

Phone: 020 7359 4404

Website: almeida.co.uk

Tube: The Angel

Reviewed by Lizzie Loveridge 

at the Almeida

at the evening performance 

on 18th December 2024