Autobiographical Fiction

“The lesson being, don’t get caught!”

Edward Fox-Ingleby

Rhiannon Needs as Miss Appleby and James Mack as Edward Fox-Ingleby (Photo: Matt Crockett)

Yes the “c” word, a CAD!  Ian Hislop and Nick Newman, in conjunction with the Watermill at Newbury, have brought us perfect and witty dramas like The Wipers Times  and SpikeHere they adapt for the stage the 1938 satirical novel by Scotsman AG Macdonnell about a fictional and unscrupulous Conservative politician Edward Percival Fox-Ingleby, who builds a complete fiction about who he is and what he stands for. 

Although AG Macdonnell’s political satires never achieved sales beyond favourable critical reviews, there is a record in the theatre programme by assistant director, Elsa Strachan of someone he did impress.  “One person who did take notice, however was Josef Goebbels.  He misread the satirical nature of the book believing it to be a genuine account. He even used it as inspiration for German wartime propaganda against the English, writing in his journal: ‘I read a book by the Englishman (sic) Macdonnell, an unspeakably frivolous and cynical concoction that shows the English plutocrat without his mask. Simply horrifying’.” 

The frame for the play is that in the late 1930s, Fox-Ingleby (James Mack) in his stately home, is dictating his autobiography to Miss Constance Appleby (Rhiannon Neads) who is clacking away on an old fashioned typewriter.  Mr Collins (Mitesh Soni) is his librarian researcher but whose corrections are ignored as Fox-Ingleby spins the version that puts him in the most positive light.  Throughout his life story, James Mack plays Fox Ingleby and the other two actors are called upon to take every other part in a miracle of costume change and characterisation, especially from Rhiannon Neads for everybody from chorus girls to wife, from grandmother to American mistress. 

James Mack as Edward Fox-Ingleby and Mitesh Soni as his nemesis (Photo: Matt Crockett)

On the walls of the stately home are paintings of the Fox-Ingleby ancestors who too have had their histories airbrushed into fame rather than infamy by their descendant. Headlines unfurl on banners of notoriety. There are his schooldays at Eton where he claims he was a “wet bob” but not in school’s Eight, but it is an opportunity to wear a boater and play the “Eton Boating Song”.  From Eton he goes to Oxford and joins the Bullingdon Club for mindless destruction and after Oxford he discovers women and theatre, chorus girls being the attraction. 

1914 sees the First World War and Fox-Ingleby’s ability to avoid anything which is actual combat. From his desk job in a supply role he controls contracts and makes a fortune for himself in munitions.  Onto a parliamentary career and marriage and an heir whose name he cannot recall and seeing as it is Fox-Ingleby, infidelity.

Despite energetic performances, this play is surprisingly without charm, as is Fox-Ingleby himself, and in need of a good edit.  There is no real journey taken and the result feels one note. This production is very disappointing after finding both The Wipers Times and Spike to be brilliant theatre. 

Rhiannon Needs as his mistress and James Mack as Edward Fox-Ingleby (Photo; Matt Crockett)

Production Notes

The Autobiography of a Cad

Written by Ian Hislop and Nick Newman 

Based on the novel by AG Macdonnell

Directed by Paul Hart

Cast

Starring:

James Mack

Mitesh Soni

Rhiannon Neads

Creatives

Director: Paul Hart

Designer:  Ceci Calf

Lighting Designer:  Charly Dunford

Choreographer:  Emily Holt

Sound Director:  Steven Atkinson

Video/projection designer: Rachel Sampley

Information

Running Time: Two hours 40 minutes including the interval

Booking to 22nd March 2025

Theatre: 

Watermill Theatre

Bagnor,

Newbury

RG20 8AE

Box Office: 01635 46044

Website: watermill.org.uk

Reviewed by Lizzie Loveridge

at the Watermill Theatre

on 14th February 2025